The poorest half of the world produces 7% of global carbon emissions. The richest 7% produces half the carbon emissions. – The Economist
An article in the Economist that argued that attempts at curbing population growth isn’t an answer to scarce resources caught my attention because of the two sentences above.
Even without looking at the figures that have been quoted to define the ‘poorest half’ or the ‘richest 7%’, I can safely assume, given that I am a poor graduate student in the UK, that I fall under neither of two categories of the world population. What does that say about my carbon emissions? Not much.
But I know that working in a synthetic chemistry lab that is air-conditioned, living in a house that has central heating and flying back home to India once a year probably means that my carbon emissions lie on the higher end of the spectrum. I do not take pride in this, but the choices that I made with the best intentions for my career have put me in this situation. I am well aware of my situation and I try my best to do something about it:
- I chose to become a pescetarian.
- I campaigned for a meatless day a week.
- I don’t shy away from asking difficult questions.
- I ensure lights are off when they are not needed.
- I turn off taps if the water isn’t being used.
- I turn off the heater in my room when I’m not there.
- I use a bicycle to go anywhere <10 miles.
I do this despite all the wasteful habits that people around me have. I have housemates who have no qualms leaving lights turned on. I have lab-mates who never think twice before mixing chlorinated waste with non-chlorinated waste. I have friends who won’t mind having a hot water bath everyday. I watch students in college halls everyday pile up food in their plates and then throw heaps of it in the bins because they’re ‘so full’. Every time I watch this happening, a little bunny dies inside me.
If I start calculating how much emissions I cut by following the things I listed above, the number will probably be small. Small enough to make me wonder, especially looking at those around me, what difference do I make?
But then I think that I do what I do not just for the absolute contribution that I make to cut emissions, but also because I care about the environment. I believe that it is important to be as morally responsible to your future generations as possible. I know that beliefs that I build today are going to affect my decisions to tomorrow. These decisions may well have large consequences then.
I’ve had a discussion about these little things that I do with many people. Some of them have wondered whether the effort I put in to doing them is worth the impact they make. Of course I believe the effort is worth it, especially if you take into account the effect of one’s belief systems. But actually, the effort put into doing them is much smaller than most people imagine it to be. Most of the little things I do have become a habit. I don’t have to consciously think that I should turn off the lights or turn off the heater, I just do it.
The other argument that I’ve come across is this: the fact that I do little things I give myself the pleasure of believing that I make some difference. In effect, I am more liable to not worry about the larger problem because in my own little world I am doing plenty. Actually, this argument has got the logic all wrong. If I do the little things, I am only more likely to do bigger things (like giving up meat or campaigning). As I said before, doing these little things has become a habit for me and I don’t derive ‘pleasure believing that I make some difference’ every time I turn off the light in an unoccupied room. So it’s definitely not offsetting me from the larger goal.
5 thoughts on “What difference do I make?”
I think it’s important to calculate (rough) numbers so that we can concentrate our effort towards effective strategies. Some of the items on your list may be more than 1000x as effective as others, and it’s important to know which is which.
Agreed but don’t you think attitude matters as much if not more?
[…] Curious Bends ← What difference do I make? […]
Those are all great steps to take and honestly those don’t make much of a difference. Sure if everyone did those and more steps toward being greener than it would make a small drop in the bucket. Alternative energy sources and focusing on commercial CO2 emissions are really the largest hurtles to cross, but they would make the biggest difference.
Spread the word!
and i like a meatless day a week too.
also I wonder where the economist got that “statistic”
[…] I’ve previously written about my opinion on seeking work with the aim of making an impact on the world. I believe that, while considering career options, that criterion must be given weight, but not too much. This struck me when I realised that, in my own search for a career, I had been focusing on making an impact more than I should have, and it was causing me distress. […]